CAREER AND WORK OF HARVEY W. SCOTT 103

the facts as clearly and as briefly as possible. His judg- ments and opinions, his preferences and resentments, his loves and his hates if they were exploited, and candor re- quires me to say that they were all exploited at times, the place was in the editorial page. The integrity of the news Mr. Scott always scrupulously respected. The reports of The Oregonian were commonly as fair to those whose ambitions or courses it opposed as those it wished to promote. I recall in this connection the publication in full made from shorthand notes an exceptional thing in those days of Senator Mitch- ell's address to the legislature upon the occasion of his second election. 14 The Oregonian had fought Mitchell with all its powers, but when he was elected his address of thanks to the legislature and through the legislature to the public was given verbatim. Mr. Mitchell himself was greatly surprised by it indeed, so much surprised that when I met him in the lobby of the old Chemeketa Hotel the following morning he forgot that we were not on speaking terms. Addressing me abruptly in the presence of half a roomful he said : "I want to say that while I abate nothing with respect to differences between Mr. Scott and myself I do respect his integrity as an editor. I was ashamed this morning to find myself surprised at the com- pleteness of the report of yesterday's doings at the Capitol. Yes, I ought to have known that as a journalist no matter about other things Mr. Scott is a man of strict integrity."

In the many controversies in which The Oregonian engaged with individuals, much was said that was severe. Much per- haps was said that would have been left unsaid upon reflec- tion. But invariably the man assailed was given opportunity to present his side of the issue, even to the length of open disrespect and downright denunciation. Only in one respect can I discover any just criticism of Mr. Scott's practice in such matters. This exception was upon calculation under the no- tion that it was justified a notion in which I could never quite coincide. Mr. Scott would always print an opponent's letter, but occasionally he would damn it with a "smashing"

14 Elected November 18, 1885; died December 8, 1905.