4
I believe btc will have a lot higher economic activity at the time of the fork. If anyone sends funds in btc, what stops someone who don't like btc2x to just replay that same transaction on btc2x? This will shuffle around funds, to different adresses and cause lots of funds to end up in wallets that are never found.
One of the protections against replay attacks is to first move the other coin to a new wallet first, but if someone automatically moves the coins in the other wallet aswell by publishing the same transaction to the other network, this protection won't work.
really helpful. This doesn't sound great though... – Kristoffer Nolgren – 2017-10-29T11:21:47.837
How does coinbase solve this? – Kristoffer Nolgren – 2017-10-29T12:23:04.410
@KristofferNolgren coinbase transactions generate new BTC. Those new BTC would not be valid unless someone did the effort of mining the other block simply to give their coins away. Therefore, the coinbase coins are safe. – Elliot A. – 2017-10-30T00:47:29.137
1
@KristofferNolgren: Not as in Coinbase.com the company, but coinbase transaction as in the transaction that collects block subsidy and fees. It is unique because it changes with the transactions collected in the block as well as the miner payout address.
– Murch – 2017-10-30T13:04:30.880