Fees depend on where you buy bitcoins, if you buy on Bitstamp fees range from 0.25% of the transaction down to 0.1% depending on the volume.
In your case it would have been 0.25% which in $ would have been 5$. Well looks like the fee you've paid is way too high.
But not everybody buys on a market like bitstamp unless you are trading, thus your other option would have been something like localbitcoins, if you compare prices there you will be paying around 20$ more for each bitcoin so since one bitcoin is around 900$ and you needed to change 2000 you would have paid much more in fees here (around 65$) but not even close to the 600$ you have paid.
The thing is, how do you know you have 1400$? haven't you changed your $ to bitcoins? In case you are just converting the value of the bitcoins to $ then you may not be being ripped off by anyone. Price of bitcoin is too volatile, for instance the price went from 1100$ one single bitcoin to 750$ in just 1 week, so if you bought your bitcoins on january 4th you would have almost 2 bitcoins, after a week on january 11th your 2 bitcoins would be worth 1500$ that is pretty much the amount you are claiming to have been ripped of from you so if this is the case you have only been ripped off by the market itself :).
If you think bitcoin has future keep your bitcoins and on June you might have doubled the amount of $ you will be paid for those bitcoins, on the other hand the price may drop and you might get half the $.
Playing with bitcoins is not for the faint of heart, but if you need to do business with bitcoins you have other options that will be safe for you. There are places like coinbase where you can be paid on bitcoins and receive the dollars (except for the fees which are not abusive), or you can pay with bitcoins if you need to. Transactions are almost immediate and you won't be suffering the volatility of the market.
You will need to do your research though and see what is the best option for your business.
1There should be a complete paper trail from the moment of purchase all the way through to the receipt of the bitcoin transactions on the other side. Can you have your IT guy produce this trail? – brandondoge – 2016-12-13T20:27:16.233
@brandondoge Thank you for taking the time to answer my question. I will certainly ask him to produce the paper trail, but just on a gut level does this seem suspicious to you? 30% in fees seem astronomical to me... – Baxter – 2016-12-15T23:12:04.263