Why is the phrase "Received with" used instead of "Received to"?

-2

Even though I'm not a native English speaker, I feel that "received to" (some address) is more understandable or more naturally sounding to an average user than "received with". Is there any specific reason why "with" is consistently used in Bitcoin software?

As an analogy, if I own several e-mail addresses, I would naturally say I received an e-mail message "to" an address, not "with" it. The "with" variant seems to me to be a wallet's (ie. software's) point of view, not the user's; as in "I caught the ball with my left hand" which would be analog to "I, the wallet software, received the funds with this address". This might feel natural for a wallet programmer, but not the user.

I'm working on translating some Bitcoin software to Slovenian and would like to clear up some things like this before I make an incorrect or unclear expression get into widespread use in my language.

mazi

Posted 2012-09-30T02:46:35.540

Reputation: 434

Question was closed 2014-03-29T17:20:06.747

This question appears to be off-topic because it is about the usage of English language. It should be asked on English.stackexchange.com instead.

Murch 2014-03-29T17:20:06.747

1Normally you would use "to" to indicate the destination and "with" to indicate the mechanism. "I drove to New York with my car." In this case, all the funds went to the same place. The difference is the mechanism by which they are retrieved.David Schwartz 2012-09-30T16:42:55.503

@David: I think it's the exactly the point made by the OP. If you look at how bitcoin currently works, (any forgetting about English grammar) bitcoins are rather received to (or maybe at) an address, than received with an address (the address is not just the mechanism, but the recipient).Stéphane Gimenez 2012-09-30T21:08:52.233

See also this answer on whether the address should be considered a recipient or an internal mechanism.

mazi 2012-10-01T04:25:29.857

Answers

2

I don't think "received to" is a correct phrase in itself. You can say that "a transfer was made to my address", "I received money with my address" but not "I received money to my address". Then again, you probably should ask this question on English SE.

ThePiachu

Posted 2012-09-30T02:46:35.540

Reputation: 41 594