UPDATED: -25 when pushing multisig

2

I am trying to push this correctly signed 2/3 multisig to the network (based on Gavin's example) and I get RPC_VERIFY_ERROR = -25, //! General error during transaction or block submission:

The requests and the responses to and from the console are:

{"method":"getnewaddress","params":[]}
{"result":"n3Cet7S4meopgzYdserFUpubMnXktqnzhL","error":null}

{"method":"getnewaddress","params":[]}
{"result":"my1NmQ5L6sYAZ8yLgEooQqzZ4QDJBMPjiL","error":null}

{"method":"getnewaddress","params":[]}
{"result":"mitERWMu8NiukHaGcMYJZnkCRJK6pzAd8P","error":null}

{"method":"walletpassphrase","params":["password",10]}
{"result":null,"error":null}

{"method":"validateaddress","params":["n3Cet7S4meopgzYdserFUpubMnXktqnzhL"]}
{"result":{"isvalid":true,"address":"n3Cet7S4meopgzYdserFUpubMnXktqnzhL","ismine":true,"isscript":false,"pubkey":"0316ac09be507f3d322cfdcbe328f7e03e720cd8c0ea4cd6dbd9b59e8d61d6f55c","iscompressed":true,"account":""},"error":null}

{"method":"validateaddress","params":["my1NmQ5L6sYAZ8yLgEooQqzZ4QDJBMPjiL"]}
{"result":{"isvalid":true,"address":"my1NmQ5L6sYAZ8yLgEooQqzZ4QDJBMPjiL","ismine":true,"isscript":false,"pubkey":"02910b3e90d39339dd765f971b03369f40c58f8b071d26c4de712daea3607d4d96","iscompressed":true,"account":""},"error":null}

{"method":"validateaddress","params":["mitERWMu8NiukHaGcMYJZnkCRJK6pzAd8P"]}
{"result":{"isvalid":true,"address":"mitERWMu8NiukHaGcMYJZnkCRJK6pzAd8P","ismine":true,"isscript":false,"pubkey":"024587719be74b5998bdc32239af62c99c62dba1eadff32e57b557ad61ae66f557","iscompressed":true,"account":""},"error":null}

{"method":"dumpprivkey","params":["n3Cet7S4meopgzYdserFUpubMnXktqnzhL"]}
{"result":"cPp5fVWM5oGbBtR41quKTqJbzUHfBz13RxjEJYRRmn1vszcmiJKc","error":null}

{"method":"dumpprivkey","params":["my1NmQ5L6sYAZ8yLgEooQqzZ4QDJBMPjiL"]}
{"result":"cQhdbAErfMzZYJMusn9usCKNBDf5RaGHNhBf6xsyHzT2XGjCbseQ","error":null}

{"method":"dumpprivkey","params":["mitERWMu8NiukHaGcMYJZnkCRJK6pzAd8P"]}
{"result":"cVFY5Fm3vyQJD6VmadkCrqFDE1x69dMTcmf65Wa3G7e5EJTz3A8n","error":null}

{"method":"createmultisig","params":[2,["0316ac09be507f3d322cfdcbe328f7e03e720cd8c0ea4cd6dbd9b59e8d61d6f55c","02910b3e90d39339dd765f971b03369f40c58f8b071d26c4de712daea3607d4d96","024587719be74b5998bdc32239af62c99c62dba1eadff32e57b557ad61ae66f557"]]}
{"result":{"address":"2N4tGQhXYZoxg68zYenfixMPmXxiycteQd1","redeemScript":"52210316ac09be507f3d322cfdcbe328f7e03e720cd8c0ea4cd6dbd9b59e8d61d6f55c2102910b3e90d39339dd765f971b03369f40c58f8b071d26c4de712daea3607d4d9621024587719be74b5998bdc32239af62c99c62dba1eadff32e57b557ad61ae66f55753ae"},"error":null}

{"method":"listunspent","params":[1,9999999,[]]}
{"result":[{"txid":"024adfd176cbafa3e2b8277c6320cc91c71928a1d93cf161fcbbbe21b552a021","vout":0,"address":"n3qdUsihCUUvhVxDGSa9dTys6FQyRYtra6","scriptPubKey":"76a914f4daf7429115209dde3dbf656e297f4822a7e86488ac","amount":0.30409597,"confirmations":333},{"txid":"2ae481097bfe598054d93e643ade015df4923eca01ef1c4248369d2f76676d29","vout":0,"address":"mgTNUvatqaoondmCKF2wrqmZp5nHfiZ41X","account":"","scriptPubKey":"76a9140a4aa70fa43aa653e932f9902c75bee703f7b6b388ac","amount":0.04900000,"confirmations":275},{"txid":"391ccc07ede180c00e11bb4a2facc0c762b2e021e96cc4ed4c5b267a2cb770d4","vout":1,"address":"muNqJMhpVEqpCBBkL3E8cP7MBFuEaYCLjB","scriptPubKey":"76a91498089826f83411d7e789adf88d2fb1732697b69d88ac","amount":0.09884210,"confirmations":333},{"txid":"69d42deda3513d73f70b5363090fcf81dd0443b1834309ea7ca5f58359344204","vout":0,"address":"mgTNUvatqaoondmCKF2wrqmZp5nHfiZ41X","account":"","scriptPubKey":"76a9140a4aa70fa43aa653e932f9902c75bee703f7b6b388ac","amount":3.24246444,"confirmations":274},{"txid":"afa0f809762154686c30cb984a340153e99a198fa5eb7abb300a90efdb9514dd","vout":0,"address":"mgTNUvatqaoondmCKF2wrqmZp5nHfiZ41X","account":"","scriptPubKey":"76a9140a4aa70fa43aa653e932f9902c75bee703f7b6b388ac","amount":0.01000000,"confirmations":275},{"txid":"cbb0939185826c02051ca82bb3696a24bf39a87109f341f7cbb58e2a9ace202e","vout":0,"address":"mtHpxHgBaazaQWrShuQKgFQTHjLyT23Jbs","scriptPubKey":"76a9148c1e19935b9c0b761850d1baff330392a062d0ff88ac","amount":0.00675471,"confirmations":356}],"error":null}

{"method":"createrawtransaction","params":[[{"txid":"024adfd176cbafa3e2b8277c6320cc91c71928a1d93cf161fcbbbe21b552a021","vout":0}],{"2N4tGQhXYZoxg68zYenfixMPmXxiycteQd1":0.30409597}]}
{"result":"010000000121a052b521bebbfc61f13cd9a12819c791cc20637c27b8e2a3afcb76d1df4a020000000000ffffffff017d03d0010000000017a9147faacb8d21673992204a50440b1321f662fa92ae8700000000","error":null}

{"method":"signrawtransaction","params":["010000000121a052b521bebbfc61f13cd9a12819c791cc20637c27b8e2a3afcb76d1df4a020000000000ffffffff017d03d0010000000017a9147faacb8d21673992204a50440b1321f662fa92ae8700000000",null,null,"ALL"]}
{"result":{"hex":"010000000121a052b521bebbfc61f13cd9a12819c791cc20637c27b8e2a3afcb76d1df4a02000000006a473044022067e51a61dc767166d10741f2ec5950eedfbbb84c5522c0db46f9809bbd91edf10220583f5e3ab5c312b8ebfb5dc5e76b11e4bdf037dd89f2447fe15c11298b2cdeed0121024c4e2909b43dac78086b040e43b161408a0e019b686f0b1754e839f2604b14f0ffffffff017d03d0010000000017a9147faacb8d21673992204a50440b1321f662fa92ae8700000000","complete":true},"error":null}

{"method":"decoderawtransaction","params":["010000000121a052b521bebbfc61f13cd9a12819c791cc20637c27b8e2a3afcb76d1df4a02000000006a473044022067e51a61dc767166d10741f2ec5950eedfbbb84c5522c0db46f9809bbd91edf10220583f5e3ab5c312b8ebfb5dc5e76b11e4bdf037dd89f2447fe15c11298b2cdeed0121024c4e2909b43dac78086b040e43b161408a0e019b686f0b1754e839f2604b14f0ffffffff017d03d0010000000017a9147faacb8d21673992204a50440b1321f662fa92ae8700000000"]}
{"result":{"txid":"65410ac69571208ec2e92603c235d9424f18778131006d34a5516783c88c7bd1","version":1,"locktime":0,"vin":[{"txid":"024adfd176cbafa3e2b8277c6320cc91c71928a1d93cf161fcbbbe21b552a021","vout":0,"scriptSig":{"asm":"3044022067e51a61dc767166d10741f2ec5950eedfbbb84c5522c0db46f9809bbd91edf10220583f5e3ab5c312b8ebfb5dc5e76b11e4bdf037dd89f2447fe15c11298b2cdeed01 024c4e2909b43dac78086b040e43b161408a0e019b686f0b1754e839f2604b14f0","hex":"473044022067e51a61dc767166d10741f2ec5950eedfbbb84c5522c0db46f9809bbd91edf10220583f5e3ab5c312b8ebfb5dc5e76b11e4bdf037dd89f2447fe15c11298b2cdeed0121024c4e2909b43dac78086b040e43b161408a0e019b686f0b1754e839f2604b14f0"},"sequence":4294967295}],"vout":[{"value":0.30409597,"n":0,"scriptPubKey":{"asm":"OP_HASH160 7faacb8d21673992204a50440b1321f662fa92ae OP_EQUAL","hex":"a9147faacb8d21673992204a50440b1321f662fa92ae87","reqSigs":1,"type":"scripthash","addresses":["2N4tGQhXYZoxg68zYenfixMPmXxiycteQd1"]}}]},"error":null}

{"method":"getnewaddress","params":[]}
{"result":"mhfP4ayuaUnwHvbhumWhVbhu3TEyjVSAA7","error":null}

{"method":"createrawtransaction","params":[[{"txid":"65410ac69571208ec2e92603c235d9424f18778131006d34a5516783c88c7bd1","vout":0}],{"mhfP4ayuaUnwHvbhumWhVbhu3TEyjVSAA7":0.2584815745}]}
{"result":"0100000001d17b8cc8836751a5346d00318177184f42d935c20326e9c28e207195c60a41650000000000ffffffff015d698a01000000001976a9141788411f512e2e7cfd311acb48f878991a2a9f1188ac00000000","error":null}

{"method":"signrawtransaction","params":["0100000001d17b8cc8836751a5346d00318177184f42d935c20326e9c28e207195c60a41650000000000ffffffff015d698a01000000001976a9141788411f512e2e7cfd311acb48f878991a2a9f1188ac00000000",[{"txid":"65410ac69571208ec2e92603c235d9424f18778131006d34a5516783c88c7bd1","vout":0,"scriptPubKey":"a9147faacb8d21673992204a50440b1321f662fa92ae87","redeemScript":"52210316ac09be507f3d322cfdcbe328f7e03e720cd8c0ea4cd6dbd9b59e8d61d6f55c2102910b3e90d39339dd765f971b03369f40c58f8b071d26c4de712daea3607d4d9621024587719be74b5998bdc32239af62c99c62dba1eadff32e57b557ad61ae66f55753ae"}],["cQhdbAErfMzZYJMusn9usCKNBDf5RaGHNhBf6xsyHzT2XGjCbseQ"],"ALL"]}
{"result":{"hex":"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","complete":false},"error":null}

{"method":"signrawtransaction","params":["0100000001d17b8cc8836751a5346d00318177184f42d935c20326e9c28e207195c60a416500000000b40047304402202d6d9b045489c2e014dcf035fccb0023653d4bbd20a80a576dc27f4d93806944022003a9969a9f6ba01647e5a525ad4c6f78a416ff6b700ecf7f563c7cb43f1c85a8014c6952210316ac09be507f3d322cfdcbe328f7e03e720cd8c0ea4cd6dbd9b59e8d61d6f55c2102910b3e90d39339dd765f971b03369f40c58f8b071d26c4de712daea3607d4d9621024587719be74b5998bdc32239af62c99c62dba1eadff32e57b557ad61ae66f55753aeffffffff015d698a01000000001976a9141788411f512e2e7cfd311acb48f878991a2a9f1188ac00000000",[{"txid":"65410ac69571208ec2e92603c235d9424f18778131006d34a5516783c88c7bd1","vout":0,"scriptPubKey":"a9147faacb8d21673992204a50440b1321f662fa92ae87","redeemScript":"52210316ac09be507f3d322cfdcbe328f7e03e720cd8c0ea4cd6dbd9b59e8d61d6f55c2102910b3e90d39339dd765f971b03369f40c58f8b071d26c4de712daea3607d4d9621024587719be74b5998bdc32239af62c99c62dba1eadff32e57b557ad61ae66f55753ae"}],["cVFY5Fm3vyQJD6VmadkCrqFDE1x69dMTcmf65Wa3G7e5EJTz3A8n"],"ALL"]}
{"result":{"hex":"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","complete":true},"error":null}

{"method":"sendrawtransaction","params":["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",true]}
{"result":null,"error":{"code":-25,"message":""}}

Related:

What could be wrong?

Doug Peters

Posted 2015-01-25T04:17:14.313

Reputation: 1 326

1Can you give a link to the UTXO you are trying to spend? I went to blockchain.info and searched for e5404d712e7445e7af4050beb33e56d79c815422f6bebe3fce6245efcddab7db but I got an error: Sorry we could not find any blocks or transactions matching this hash. – morsecoder – 2015-01-25T16:02:47.867

@StephenM347 correct, it's not on the blockchain, I am trying to replicate Gavin's example: https://gist.github.com/gavinandresen/3966071

– Doug Peters – 2015-01-25T17:27:33.480

In that example, gavin made two transactions (the second depending on the first), and showed that you can make the second transaction ahead of time and then send it out after the first one is published. Maybe you are sending them in the reverse order? Long story short, though, if the previous output isn't on the blockchain or in your mempool, then you can't really push a new transaction that depends on it onto the blockchain. – morsecoder – 2015-01-25T17:32:00.043

Can you include the raw hex of the transaction that this transaction depends on in your question? – morsecoder – 2015-01-25T17:44:04.803

@StephenM347 I have updated my question with a fresh example, ineluding the information you requested. – Doug Peters – 2015-01-26T01:13:05.770

could you copy paste the commands you run? – Ruben de Vries – 2015-01-26T22:00:51.657

@RubendeVries I have updated my question, thanks. – Doug Peters – 2015-01-27T03:12:02.767

Answers

1

afaik - 25 only happens if the output you're trying to use is already spent (either confirmed in the chain or by a TX in your mempool)

Ruben de Vries

Posted 2015-01-25T04:17:14.313

Reputation: 546

I take a random input from listunspent for the tx that pays the multisig. The test core doesn't create any other txs so it couldn't be spent. It couldn't be on the blockchain either since I never send it over. It's a very weird case. – Doug Peters – 2015-01-26T21:52:55.187

Asked: 2015-01-25T04:17:14.313

Viewed: 181 times

Active: 2015-01-27T03:11:02.870