If there was a period of time with no transactions, what would miners have to do?

This question is similar to a few others, but I haven't gotten seen a clear answer anywhere. It came up as I was trying to explain mining to a newcomer. And he asked: "If aliens came and put all humans to sleep ( and any automated transactions that may have been setup ) would miners have anything to do?"

So the question is, if zero transactions are happening, are miners still mining? And if yes, what exactly are they doing?

I explained also that eventually block rewards will end, so I'm looking for an answer that is agnostic of the bitcoin network now vs the post-block rewards bitcoin network ( after the 21 million are "mined" )

markjwill

Posted 2013-08-09T20:24:04.417

Reputation: 183

– Murch – 2014-02-03T23:51:58.613

Answers

They would mine empty blocks. Block difficulty would remain the same.

Would they have an incentive to mine blocks? In the year 2140, all mining rewards will be from fees. If there are no transactions, there are no fees. Between now and then, rewards will step down over time. So either:

Clients will keep mining.
Clients will stop mining because there are no transactions.

I recognize that this is a useless answer (maybe they will, maybe they won't) but I hope you understand the difficulty of predicting what mining clients will be like in 5-10 years.

Nick ODell

Posted 2013-08-09T20:24:04.417

Reputation: 26 536

"They would mine empty blocks." Is all i was looking for.. But that also leads me to: Would miners still have a hash rate when mining "empty blocks"? Would the answer be different post block rewards? – markjwill – 2013-08-12T12:54:02.150

In order: Yes. Yes. – Nick ODell – 2013-08-12T17:40:18.300

There is virtually no "empty blocks". All blocks except the genesis block is actually headed by the hash of preceding block and then followed by the miners reward of the previous block in terms of the first transaction of the current block. Therefore there should always be at least one transaction.

James Fung

Posted 2013-08-09T20:24:04.417

Reputation: 41

That's like asking "what will banks do if no one spends money, no one takes out loans, and everyone shreds their credit cards".

I would assume JPMorgan in that situation would shut its financial servers down to save electricity.

Dre4dwolf

Posted 2013-08-09T20:24:04.417

Reputation: 59